The idea of two verbs for “to be” may be difficult at first. (Although the idea is not totally unknown...) But these are the finer details where we really learn the types of being that can be talked about.

notes/summaries

The Copula
Notes on Myles Dillon: Chapter 8
page 9 of 12
These summaries are from notebooks I created in 1999 for my website on xoom.com. They are revised and reposted here, in hope that they will continue be useful. It is meant to used along with the original text. Consult that for more information.
T

á is used for “to be” in sentences of description:

Tá an hata ar an mbord.
(The hat is on the table.)

Tá an lá fuar.
(The day is cold.)

Tá an mála folamh.
(The bag is empty.)


return to top

The copula is (rhymes with hiss) is used in sentences of definition and identity. Is generally joins two nouns. The distinction between and is is like the distinction between the Spanish ser and estar.

[Two other languages in the same Indo-European family also have a similar pair of distinct “to be” verbs. They are Sanskrit, which has “as” and “bhur” and Persian (Farsi).]

Present Past/ Conditional
is mé
is thú/ tú
is í/é
is sinn
is sibh
is iad
ba mé
ba thú/ tú
ba í/é
ba sinn
ba sibh
ba iad

Copula sentences change the normal word order. The copula is found in sentences of two basic types: definition and identity.

return to top


A sentence of definition says what the subject is.

Cad Cormac? Is rí Cormac. (What is Cormac? Cormac is a King.)
Cad é? Is úll é. (What is it? It is an apple.)

The predicate of a sentence of definition must be indefinite ( a king, an apple) and must not be a personal pronoun. The subject can be either definite or indefinite. Because the predicate of the sentence of definition is indefinite, the sentence will not usually express an equality. Cormac is a king but a king is not necessarily Cormac. He may be Arthur or Charles, etc.

The word order in a sentence of definition is usually verb-predicate-subject.

verb predicate subject meaning
is
is
is
is
is
leabhar
fir

cailín óg
cloch
é
iad
Cormac
Máire
í
it is a book.
they are men
Cormac is a king.
Mary is a young girl
it is a stone

Many sentences of definition contain a demonstrative (seo, sin, etc.) in the subject, but the word order is still verb-predicate-subject.

verb predicate subject meaning
is
is
is
is
leabhar
fir
speal
bord
é seo
iad san
í siúd
é sin
this is a book.
those are men.
that (over there) is a scythe.
that is a table.

The question words associated with sentences of definition are Cad? and Céard? Both mean what?

To place special emphasis on the predicate in the sentence of definition, a new word order is used and the old neuter pronoun is also introduced. The new order is predicate-verb-subject.

predicate verb subject meaning
fear
scian ghlan
leabhar Gaeilge
Múinteoir
is
is
is
is
ea
ea
ea
ea
é
í seo
é sin
Séan
it is a man .
this is a clean knife.
That is an Irish book.
Séan is a teacher.

In the normal verb-predicate-subject word order of the sentence of definition, special emphasis may be added to a noun-subject by inserting the appropriate pronoun into the subject before the noun. the old neuter pronoun is not used.

verb predicate subject meaning
is
is
is
is
múinteoir maith
cailín óg
dochtúirí
gadhair
é
í
iad
iad
Seán.
Máire
na daoine sin
ár bpeatí
Seán is a good teacher.
Mary is a young girl.
those people are doctors.
our pets are dogs.


return to top

The sentence of identity asks who or which the subject is.

is í casog Sheáin í (It is Seán's coat.)
is mise Séamas. (I am Séamas.)

In a sentence of identity, both the subject and the predicate must be a definite noun, pronoun or phrase that is definite in meaning. The sentence of identity looks for equalities. Both terms refer to specific objects and they are interchangeable.

it= Seán's coat and Seán's coat=it.
I = Séamas and Séamas = I.

The basic form of a sentence of identity has a split subject: verb-subject-predicate-subject.

verb subject predicate subject meaning
is
is
is
is
é
iad
é
iad
an leabhar
na garsúin
Seán
na Sasanaigh
é
iad
é
iad
it is the book.
they are the boys.
it is Seán.
they are the English.

The emphasis is put on the predicate and it distinguishes it from other meanings.

The book, not the paper or the pen.
the boys, not the girls or the men.
Seán, not Pól or Síle
The English, not the Americans or the Germans.

It follows also, that the subject in this pattern is going to be a pronoun.

A different form is used when the subject is a demonstrative. The subject is not split, so the pattern is the same as that used with : verb-subject-predicate.

verb subject predicate meaning
is
is
is
is
é sin
iad so
í siúd
í seo
an leabhar.
na garsúin.
Síle.
mo lamh.
that is the book.
these are the boys
that (over there) is Shiela.
this is my hand.

If both the subject and the predicate are definite nouns and not pronouns, then the term to be emphasised comes first. Either verb-subject-predicate or verb-predicate-subject are possible depending on the sense. A definite noun cannot follow the copula directly, so the appropriate pronoun is inserted after the verb.

verb first term second term meaning
is
is
is
is
í
é
é
iad
Cáit
an fear san
an fear beag
na Gearmánaigh
mo bhean.
an sagart.
an captaen.
mo chairde.
Cáit is my wife.
That man is the priest.
The captain isthe small man.
My friends are the Germans.
VSP

VPS

In a sentence of identity where the first term is a demonstrative subject like: “is é an fear.” the subject may be turned around and the verb dropped so that you get: sin é an fear.

In fact, the verb may be understood and dropped anytime the first term begins with:

verb subject predicate meaning
--
--
--
--
sin é
sin iad
sin é
mise
an fear.
mo bhróga-sa.
an captaen.
an dochtúr
that is the man.
those are my shoes.
that is the captain.
I am the doctor.

The verb may not be dropped when the subject is a pronoun alone.

Summary:

sentences of definition
I. is fear é. VPS basic form

fear is ea é PVS emphasis on predicate.
sentences of identity
II. is é an fear é. VSPS emphasis on definite predicate, pronoun subject.
III. is é sin an fear. VSP demonstrative subject

sin é an fear (V)SP demonstrative subject: verb understood
IV. is é Seán mo mhac. VSP definite predicate and subject. empasis on subject.

return to top


In certain sentences of definition where emphasis is placed on the predicate, if the predicate is modified by an adjective the order within the predicate is re-arranged. The adjective is given the first position. The noun is made definite and follows the adjective.

Thus: is rud maith é becomes is maith an rud é.
The old neuter pronoun form *rud maith is ea é”* would not be used.

verb predicate subject meaning
is
is
is
is
breá an lá
mór an trua
laidir na fir
deas an duine
é.
é.
iad.
é.
it is a fine day.
it is a great pity.
they are strong men.
he is a nice person.

The past tense of is is ba. All forms of ba lenite a noun or adjective that follows. In ea sentences, ba becomes dob (do+b'). However some dialects use tá+ prepositional pronoun forms of i instead.

bo mhaith dob ea í sin. is buachaill maith atá ann. is bó mbaith do bhí inti.

The particles for dependent forms of is are as follows.

present
meaning past
meaning

níl
an bhfuil?
ná fuil?
go bhfuil

is

an?
nach?
gur
nach
is
isnt
is?
isnt?
that (is)
that (is) not
bhí
níor
ar?
nár?
gur
nár
ba
níor(bh)
ar(bh)?
nár(bh)?
gur(bh)
nár(bh)
was
wasnt
was?
wasnt?
that (was)
that (was) not

The verb itself is lost after these particles, so they seem to be used in place of the verb, unlike tá where it is merely added on. bh is added to past tense forms before a vowel or silent fh. Similarly ní adds an h to a following vowel as in ní hea.

present past
ní fear é
an fear é?
nach fear é?
gur fear é
nach fear é
níorbh fhear é
arbh fhear é?
nárbh fhear é
gurbh fhear é.
nárbh fhear é.

responses

Answers to questions are :
is ea ('sea) for yes
ní hea for no

in a sentence of identity is é/í and ní hé/ are used.

Hence, the old neuter is used in the sentence of definition and in the sentence of identity it is not.

In these cases it is pronounced [ɪš] as it is spelled.

To reflect this, is ea becomes 'sea
is é becomes 'sé
is í becomes 'sí

return to top